Sleuthing in Cape May’s SHERLOCK HOLMES WEEKEND

In the enchanting coastal town of Cape May, New Jersey, the Sherlock Holmes Weekend draws mystery lovers annually, bringing to life an interactive homage to Arthur Conan Doyle’s iconic detective. Over these weekends in late November, visitors don Victorian attire and roam Cape May’s historic streets in pursuit of clues to solve an original mystery.

Presented each year by Cape May’s Mid-Atlantic Center for the Arts and Humanities (MAC). This event has become a cherished tradition, offering an opportunity for visitors to fully immerse themselves in an atmospheric mystery worthy of Holmes himself.

Groups of amateur detectives dash toward the Emlen Physick Estate, eager to interview the housemaid—a costumed actor who stands at the entrance, lantern flickering in the crisp, salty air. She glances nervously at the cluster of participants, her breath visible in the cool morning, and begins, “Oh, Mister Morant wasn’t here at all last night, though we expected him to arrive at half past six,” she says, her voice hushed, laden with concern as if she might be overheard. “It wasn’t until eight fifteen that we finally decided he wasn’t going to arrive, so we put away the sherry and snuffed the candles.”

The scent of aged wood mingles with the faint smell of the sea breeze, creating an atmosphere rich with history. She frowns, casting her gaze to the ornate front door, then adds, “And he was so interested in seeing the new painting; I do hope nothing bad has happened.”

Participants press her with questions, scribbling notes and comparing theories as the famed detective duo would have done, the sound of pencils scratching against paper punctuating the stillness. The historic mansion’s flickering gas lights cast long shadows across the grounds, and each team attempts to uncover what could have waylaid the elusive Dr. Physick. One sleuth notices a faint footprint near the back door, the damp earth imprinting details in the ground, while another catches sight of an upstairs window, where the curtains seem to have shifted slightly, hinting at recent activity. The mystery deepens, pulling everyone further into the story and the secrets of Cape May’s past.

The Sherlock Holmes Weekend typically features stops at some of Cape May’s most storied and atmospheric venues, which serve as both scenic backdrops and integral pieces of the mystery puzzle. Past events have included stops at the historic Emlen Physick Estate, a striking Victorian mansion with ample grounds for hiding clues.

Other popular spots include the Inn of Cape May, a grand hotel known for its wrap-around porch and ocean views, and the Carriage House Café & Tearoom, where many enjoy an afternoon tea break to discuss their findings, just as Watson might have suggested to his partner.

The gentle sound of waves lapping against the shore and the distant call of seagulls create a unique soundscape that complements the thrilling atmosphere. These venues add layers to the mystery, allowing participants to experience Cape May’s architectural gems while piecing together clues.

A prominent stop on the mystery tour, the Emlen Physick Estate is a quintessential example of Victorian Stick-style architecture, designed in 1879 by the famed architect Frank Furness. The mansion features a distinctive asymmetrical facade, with elaborate brackets, gabled dormers, and tall chimneys that make it a commanding sight against the twilight sky. Inside, the estate is equally grand, showcasing period furnishings, original woodwork, and wallpaper reflective of the Victorian era’s eclectic tastes. The air within carries a hint of lavender and beeswax from the antique furniture, transporting visitors to late 19th-century life, with furnishings, artwork, and décor preserved to echo its original grandeur.

Cape May, New Jersey, holds the distinction of being one of the nation’s oldest seaside resorts, renowned for its stunning collection of Victorian architecture. Established in the early 1800s, it flourished as a resort destination during the Victorian era, attracting visitors seeking both leisure and the therapeutic benefits of the ocean. The town’s historic district features over 600 preserved Victorian buildings, showcasing a variety of architectural styles, including Gothic Revival, Italianate, and Queen Anne. These beautifully restored homes and hotels, often adorned with intricate gingerbread trim and vibrant color palettes, provide an atmospheric backdrop that perfectly complements the Sherlock Holmes Weekend. The fusion of mystery and history, set against the striking Victorian facades, creates a unique experience that immerses participants in the charm of a bygone era, enhancing the allure of the weekend’s activities as they unravel clues amidst Cape May’s storied past.

The exact storyline and setting of the mystery change with each iteration, lending a fresh twist to each year’s event. For instance, one year, attendees might work to exonerate an old adversary of Holmes, accused of a dark crime, while another year might see them tracking down a mysterious thief across Cape May’s storied locales.

The weekend often begins with a welcome reception, where participants meet the characters and receive a synopsis of the case—an essential briefing that would have pleased Watson. This initial gathering, filled with the buzz of excited chatter and the clinking of glassware, kicks off the search for clues, with attendees visiting various Cape May locations, including the grand Victorian mansions and scenic beach views, to gather pieces of the puzzle.

Participants are encouraged to don period costumes as they sleuth about the historic streets of Cape May during the Sherlock Holmes Weekend. The rustle of taffeta skirts and the soft thud of polished shoes on cobblestones add to the ambiance, creating a symphony of sound as they engage with the mystery unfolding around them. This immersive touch adds to the overall atmos phere, allowing attendees to fully engage with the Victorian theme of the event while they hunt for clues and interact with various characters, including those portraying Holmes and Watson.

Many choose to embrace the spirit of the era, sporting attire reminiscent of the late 19th century, which enhances the authenticity of the experience. Dressing in period costume not only heightens the enjoyment but also fosters a sense of community among participants, creating a vibrant array of characters as they unravel the mystery together, evoking the camaraderie shared between Holmes and Watson.

The weekends include interactive elements and themed gatherings, such as an afternoon tea where participants can discuss their theories or a social at one of Cape May’s historic inns or restaurants. The air fills with the rich scent of freshly brewed tea mingling with delicate pastries, providing a cozy atmosphere for sleuths to immerse themselves in the Victorian mystery experience while connecting with other enthusiasts. Prizes add a competitive edge; the grand prize typically offers a free weekend stay for the following year’s mystery, rewarding the most astute detectives—recognition that would surely delight Holmes himself.

The weekend begins with registration starting at 9:30 a.m. at the La Mer Beachfront Resort, where attendees can enjoy a continental breakfast. Following breakfast, the excitement kicks off with Act I of “Sherlock Holmes and the Familiar Face” by Jacklyn Fazio at 10 a.m., drawing participants into the mystery’s narrative. After this initial act, guests will embark on a Search for Clues Tour through the charming streets of Cape May, where they’ll compete for a grand prize: a weekend getaway for two to next year’s performance. Act II resumes at 2 p.m. with light refreshments served, allowing participants to discuss their findings and theories.

On the second day, the fun begins with lunch served at 11:30 a.m., setting the stage for the concluding Act III, which commences at 12:30 p.m. A cash bar will be available for those wishing to enjoy refreshments as the thrilling mystery unfolds to its resolution.

La Mer Beachfront Resort is ideally suited for the Sherlock Holmes Weekend activities for several reasons. First, its prime beachfront location provides a picturesque backdrop, immersing participants in the charm of Cape May while allowing easy access to nearby venues where various events take place. The sound of waves crashing against the shore creates a soothing backdrop, enhancing the experience of solving mysteries by the sea. The resort’s facilities offer comfortable accommodations, allowing attendees to unwind after a day of clue-hunting and mystery-solving.

La Mer Beachfront Resort, located in Cape May, New Jersey, is a family-owned establishment that first opened in 1969. Under the ownership of the Andy family, the resort has expanded over the years, creating a blend of classic beachfront ambiance with modern amenities. Known for its recent renovations, La Mer now offers a range of accommodations designed to emphasize both comfort and coastal luxury. The resort’s prime location on the Cape May beach allows guests immediate access to the shore, with each room offering amenities like private balconies, kitchenettes, and high-quality bedding.

The on-site Pier House restaurant provides seasonal cuisine with a focus on fresh, locally sourced ingredients, enhancing the beachfront dining experience. The sounds of clinking dishes and cheerful conversations fill the air, creating a lively atmosphere for guests to savor their meals while overlooking the ocean. From weddings to small corporate gatherings, La Mer also offers event spaces tailored for memorable gatherings by the sea, complete with in-house catering options. The resort’s longstanding reputation and dedication to providing an elegant yet welcoming atmosphere make it a unique part of the Cape May experience.

Participants in the Sherlock Holmes Weekend are not required to stay at La Mer Beachfront Resort, although it serves as the host hotel and provides convenient accommodations. Attendees have the freedom to choose from a range of lodging options throughout Cape May, including charming bed and breakfasts, other hotels, and vacation rentals. While many enjoy exploring the town’s diverse offerings, staying at La Mer can enhance the experience by offering easy access to the weekend’s activities and potential special rates for event participants.

The Sherlock Holmes is a collaborative effort led by Cape May MAC (Museum + Arts + Culture), which organizes the event. This local organization has been a key player in designing and running this immersive mystery experience since its inception in 1990. They bring the fictional world of Holmes to life through actors portraying Holmes, Dr. Watson, and other characters, engaging participants in a town-wide mystery filled with clues and interactive performances that would please even the keenest sleuth.

The event is also supported by local businesses and venues that provide accommodations, host themed receptions, and participate in the self-guided clue hunt across Cape May’s historic sites. Local actors and guides contribute by performing in costume, their voices blending with the sound of the ocean breeze, enhancing the Victorian ambiance and creating a theatrical atmosphere that immerses visitors in a Holmesian experience. These collaborations between the MAC, local actors, and business owners make it possible to run a complex, interactive event that attracts mystery enthusiasts from around the country, reminiscent of the camaraderie shared by Holmes and Watson in their adventures.

In addition to aiding Holmes and Watson in their quest for justice, participants can indulge in a variety of activities that celebrate the rich history and charm of Cape May. Attendees can stroll along the picturesque streets, admiring the beautifully preserved Victorian architecture that sets the stage for the weekend’s intrigue. Local shops will showcase themed merchandise, offering unique souvenirs to commemorate the occasion. Food lovers can savor delicious offerings from nearby restaurants, many featuring special menus inspired by the Victorian era. Additionally, guided tours of historical sites provide insights into the town’s fascinating past, allowing visitors to engage with its storied heritage. Whether enjoying a cozy cup of tea, participating in interactive workshops, or simply soaking in the festive atmosphere, there’s something for everyone as they immerse themselves in this unforgettable weekend of mystery and adventure.

Admission for the weekend experience is set at $150 per person, which includes access to all three acts of the performance and meals throughout the event. For those wishing to extend their stay, significant discounts on accommodations at the La Mer Beachfront Resort are available. Attendees can take advantage of these special rates by booking online through the Cape May MAC website, making it convenient to secure a comfortable place to relax after an engaging day of mystery and exploration in Cape May. Advance purchase of tickets is required due to limited availability, so early reservation is highly recommended to ensure participation in this unique theatrical experience.

All photos coutesy of Cape May MAC.

Cape May’s Sherlock Holmes Weekend has blossomed into a thrilling blend of drama, camaraderie, and Victorian charm, and the 2024 event is set to deliver even more excitement. Scheduled for November 16-17 and 23-24, 2024, this year’s play, titled “Sherlock and the Familiar Face,” will see Holmes confronting a difficult dilemma when a former adversary is accused of a heinous crime.

The weekend promises engaging performances, and participants can compete for the grand prize of a weekend for two at next year’s performance. With costumes encouraged, the atmosphere will be alive with the spirit of the Victorian era, making it a delightful experience for both locals and visitors alike. Join in the fun, immerse yourself in this captivating world, and remember—the game is afoot!

For more information

• capemaymac.org
• capemaylamer.com